Dietary Guides

This page features notes I have found on dietary guidelines in Chinese medicine. They are based upon pattern diagnosis and designed to balance the excesses and deficiencies within our bodies.

One important factor in Chinese dietary therapy is taste, for which this article in Herbal Reality provides an excellent introduction based on the Su Wen ch. 22. Following is my own analysis and comparison to Su Wen ch. 10 which appears on the surface to contradict this and challenge the generally accepted notion that each flavour supplements its associated Zang.

Su Wen ch. 22 says:

  • "Acridity disperses
  • Sourness contracts
  • Sweetness relaxes
  • Bitterness hardens
  • Saltiness softens"
Which can be applied to various Zangfu patterns through their relationship to the Wuxing:
  • "The Liver longs for dispersion... Quickly consume the acrid to disperse it. Use acridity to supplement it, sourness to drain it.
  • The Heart longs for softness... Quickly consume saltiness to soften it. Use saltiness to supplement it, sweetness to drain it.
  • The Spleen longs for relaxation... Quickly consume sweetness to relax it. Use bitterness to drain it and sweetness to supplement it.
  • The Lung longs for contraction... Quickly consume sourness to contract it. Use sourness to supplement it and acridity to drain it.
  • The Kidneys long for hardness... Quickly consume bitterness to harden them. Use bitterness to supplement them and saltiness to drain them."
These may seem counter-intuitive to people brought up on the basic Five Element flavours but this pattern probably developed from the simpler image of the four elements at four points of a cross with the Earth in the centre. In practice, bitterness tends to be used to drain Heat and Fire, associated with the Heart, with the author of this chapter perhaps opting for a gentler approach for the Heart, returning it to the central balance, rather than forcefully draining the "Sovereign Organ," and instead using bitter to drain the Spleen of Dampness.

On this basis we can see that each Zang's own flavour tends to drain, while its opposite supplements, with the exception of the Spleen. Sweetness encourages relaxation and return to the centre, supplementing the Spleen, but excessive centralisation results in a lack of movement which can lead to stagnation and Dampness. Meanwhile bitterness, that has not been applied to draining for the aforementioned taboo on controlling the Sovereign, is instead applied to the Spleen. Fire has an energetic, rising quality, and bitterness, which should drain Fire, counters this with a strong downward movement towards the lower orifices. This makes it ideal for expelling Dampness which should naturally gravitate towards the bladder (and occasionally bowel) to be purged. Bitterness is also described as hardening, which can be rationally seen as the opposite of the relaxing property of sweetness.

This is contradicted by Su Wen ch. 10 which states:

"If one consumes large quantities of saltiness, then the blood vessels will congeal to become impeded and the complexion changes. If one consumes large quantities of bitterness, then the skin will desiccate and the body hair is plucked out. If one consumes large quantities of acridity, then the sinews become tense and the nails dry. If one consumes large quantities of sourness, then the flesh hardens and shows wrinkles and the lips peel. If one consumes large quantities of sweetness, then the bones will ache and the hair on the head falls off. These are the harms resulting from the five flavours. Hence, the Heart longs for bitterness, The Lung longs for acridity. The Liver longs for sourness. The Spleen longs for sweetness. The Kidneys long for saltiness."
This appears to be using the later model of the Wuxing as a circle and the controlling cycle but a closer examination reveals some inconsistencies with this idea. The flavours mentioned are said in Su Wen 22 to drain the associated Zang, so it should end up decreasing that Zang's controlling influence. It could be explained away by simply saying that the two chapters were from two schools of thought, and this is clearly the case in the flavours each Zang "longs for" which opposite in most cases, but clinically it helps if we have a consistent system to decide exactly what a flavour does to our body instead of having two contradictory answers. It can be resolved if we consider that in Su Wen 22 the all Zang yearn for their tonifying flavour to counter a sudden deficiency, while in Su Wen 10 they yearn for their draining flavour, except the Spleen, with bitter this time applying to Fire and the Heart without the taboo against draining it directly. This does imply different schools of supplementing and draining, but with less contradiction. It is also notable that the Zang of East and South, the two Yang directions, seem to suffer from Excess conditions (sinew tension, suggesting Qi Stagnation, and congealing Blood, suggesting Blood Stasis), while the Zang of the West and North suffer mainly deficiency (dry skin, suggesting Blood deficiency, and aching bones with hair loss, suggesting Jing deficiency). Moreover, the South and North seem to be exclusively Excess and Deficient, while the East and West have some of both (brittle nails suggesting some Blood Deficiency, while the hair being "plucked out" suggests some Excess Pathogen forcibly removing it, rather than it simply falling out). The Spleen is an unusual Zang in that it actually moves in all four directions, raising clear Yang while Stomach Qi descends, holding the Blood (inward) while governing the transforming of food into Qi and transporting it around the body (outward). In its pathology, excess sourness causes a roughly equal amount of Excess and Deficiency and a combination of the primary pathologies of the Liver and Lung (hardening of the flesh, similar to the sinews becoming tense, while the wrinkles and peeling lips suggests the Exterior becoming deficient and dry like in pathology of the Lung). Since sourness contracts it is reasonable to expect a tendency towards Excess in the Interior (flesh hardening) with Deficiency of the Exterior (wrinkles and peeling skin). Meanwhile, sweetness is the one flavour that supplements its associated Zang, but in Su Wen 22, also gently drains the Heart by returning its extreme to the centre. This tendency towards centring could be seen as disrupting the dynamism between the two polarities of Yin and Yang that the Kidneys represent, and its draining of Fire makes it particularly affect the Kidney Yang aspect of Jing that manifests in the bones and hair.

It therefore becomes possible to annotate the above description with the following descriptions of what the flavours do and how they achieve that result:

  • If one consumes large quantities of saltiness, [Saltiness softens which supplements the relaxing properties of the Heart and drains the Kidneys leading to Fire Excess and Water Deficiency, further compounding the Excess because Water can no longer control Fire] then the blood vessels will congeal to become impeded and the complexion changes [Blood Stasis with Luo activation causing visible complexion changes].
  • If one consumes large quantities of bitterness, [Bitterness hardens and drains the Spleen with a downward action, while also supplementing the Kidneys, referring to causing more urination. This results in fluid loss from both excessive urination and Spleen deficiency failing to generate Blood and transport fluids, affecting its Taiyin partner and elemental Child, the Lung] then the skin will desiccate and the body hair is plucked out [Blood deficiency leading to severely dry skin allowing Exterior invasion to attack the body hair].
  • If one consumes large quantities of acridity, [Acridity disperses the Qi, depleting the contracting function of the Lung and supplementing the Liver's expansive nature. If it is not then released from the Exterior, Qi will stagnate under the skin, in the Sinews] then the sinews become tense and the nails dry [Qi Stagnation, especially of Wei Qi in the Sinews causing tension and preventing Blood from reaching the extremities].
  • If one consumes large quantities of sourness, [Sourness contracts opposing the expansive function of Liver and supplementing the contracting function of Lung, resulting the Qi and Blood generated by the Spleen to become constrained in the centre and not reach its intended targets] then the flesh hardens and shows wrinkles and the lips peel [Qi stagnation causing the flesh to harden while Blood and fluids fail to reach the Exterior causes wrinkles and peeling lips, a mixture of the primary pathologies of the Liver and Lung].
  • If one consumes large quantities of sweetness, [Sweetness returns to the centre, supplementing the Spleen. Excessive centralisation will reduce the dynamism of the Yin-Yang polarity that generates the entire elemental sequence, whose source is in the Kidneys] then the bones will ache and the hair on the head falls off [Kidney Jing deficiency causing signs of ageing such as aching bones and baldness].
These basic directional forces of the flavours in Su Wen 10 are easily borne out by modern insights. Excess salt causes high blood pressure which leads to clotting events and excessive sugar intake leads to diabetes which is characterised by excessive urination (bones are governed by the Kidneys). Excessive acrid, spicy foods raise Qi upwards and can cause us to feel hot and agitated like a Liver pattern, while bitter herbs are used to drain Dampness and Heat, and can lead to dryness and damage to Spleen Qi if taken in excess (interestingly, western herbalism often uses bitter tonics as digestives, but this may be a different way of describing the same action: by encouraging movement along the digestive tract, it is both draining and unblocking but also enhancing digestion by drying Dampness and promoting the downward motion of Stomach Qi). Similarly sour citrus fruits, if eaten in excess can cause digestive discomfort, bloating and gas as Dampness builds in the centre.

Dietary Guidelines:

The links below give some specific dietary recommendations for each major TCM pattern of imbalance. These may not have all the subtleties of the Nei Jing discussion above, but can be useful guides to distribute for patients. Please note that you should not restrict yourself to eating only the foods on the list but use them as suggestions for what to incorporate and avoid in your diet. Other dietary plans can also be considered and incorporated into these. Where a complex pattern is diagnosed, compare the sheets for the relevant patterns and make decisions based on the weighting of the diagnoses.

Blood Stasis

Cold Accumulation

Damp-Heat

Dampness and Phlegm

Heart Blood Deficiency

Heart Fire

Heart Qi and Yang Deficiency

Heart Yin Deficiency

Kidney Yang Deficiency

Kidney Yin Deficiency

Liver Blood Deficiency

Liver Fire

Liver Qi Stagnation

Liver Yang Rising

Liver Yin Deficiency

Lung Heat

Lung Qi Deficiency

Lung Yin Deficiency

Spleen Qi Deficiency

Spleen Yang Deficiency

Stomach Heat

Wind-Dampness